a story as sharp as a knife summary

Robert Bringhurst did a marvelous at describing the personalities, ideas and times of these men and their Haida counterparts. What I did get was slightly dizzying in scope, and I feel like I'll need to go back to it. The market craves traditional images, but tradition means a colonized version of Indian.Allan J. Ryan’s The Trickster Shift looks at 15 native artists he believes “share the same esthetic” and who “constitute a loose alliance of socially active, politically aware, and professionally trained individuals of roughly the same age.” For a couple of decades, artists such as Shelley Niro, Gerald McMaster, and Joane Cardinal-Schubert have formed a “school” of art; they write and lecture on each other, curate and show with each other.And trade one-liners. Synopsis. ... Dagger: A sharp knife . The story happened in Janet’s place. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. A Story as Sharp as a Knife will make academics tremble with jealousy and students of myth-telling shiver with excitement. Welcome back. Absolutely fascinating and probably better read more slowly or more times than I did. A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World (Masterworks of the Classical Haida Mythtellers) by Bringhurst, Robert and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at AbeBooks.com. A study of the efforts of ethnologist John Swanton to record the stories of the Haida people of British Columbia and Southeast Alaska. Ryan asks that we consider “Indianness”; so does Bringhurst. Growth! Robert Bringhurst wants to remedy the past, specifically the one missing from Ryan’s study. One of the most engrossing academic texts I have had the pleasure of reading, and that manages to do justice in its description, appreciation and study of the great oral Haida literary tradition. John Swanton, though trained by Boas, recognized the lie of colonial paraphrase and hired a Haida translator to dictate to him, syllable by syllable in the original language, the poets’ words. This book is mostly a series of epic oral poetry from a few of the remaining members of the Haida tribe - a native North American tribe living in the modern-day Queen Victoria islands off the coast of Alaska. For more than a thousand years before the Europeans came, a great culture flourished on these islands. The The Subtle Knife Community Note includes chapter-by-chapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you. Due to my lack of knowledge in various Haida nuances (some of which could have been more elaborated upon) my enjoyment of the stories was uneven, but still it is a great collection. He is the author of, (The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World), The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World, Hilary Weston Writers' Trust Prize for Nonfiction Nominee (1999), The Times Online 100 Best Books of the Decade (2000-2009). Bringhurst wrote one of my bibles, Elements of Typographic Style (anyone who works with type needs to own and study this book diligently), but the man is an awe inspiring multi disciplinary wizard. Woman (in her 30s, bottled raven hair, black velvet mini, tight mock turtle, take-me boots): “God, I luuuuv Bill Reid’s stuff. The story happened during the day. This is such a book. However, the tales, stripped of the academic appraisal, are lovely and worth reading on their own. A new book from The Folio Society republishes an important text on the mythtellers of the indigenous North American Haida people and how this distinctive oral tradition has been preserved. In her introduction Margaret Atwood describes A Story as Sharp as a Knife as a book that ‘opens locked doors, it reveals vistas, it illuminates’. The edition features a striking series of artworks from Haida artist, Don Yeomans Bringhurst also succeeded at using a entertaining writing style to make large amounts of complicated. We’d love your help. Synopsis. By Robert Bringhurst. All of this aside, reading the large sections of these myths and story cycles provided in this text is an absolute joy. My only regret was that this first book out of three did not have more content in myth alongside all of the eloquent and passionate commentary. Beautiful. This means that its skin was pointed on the top. ", Books in Canada "Bringhurst's accomplishment is beyond praise... A Story as Sharp as a Knife merits a wide readership and a passionate response. I’d kill for a ring. The question of appropriation and ownership of this material comes up frequently in Bringhurst's book, but I am not certain that he really engages with it to its fullest extent. As for his approach, which views the story cycles as high literature through a Western lens, it has its positives and its problems. This brilliant compilation of tales of Native Americans of the Northwest, including the Makah, is more academic than I expected. Bringhurst also succeeded at using a entertaining writing style to make large amounts of complicated information readable and accessible. As vital and, of course, just as easy to forget.” The poetry is good, too.Bringhurst compares these poems – he prints the original Haida, a pronunciation guide, as well as his English translations – to the works of Haydn and Beethoven, and to Homer’s Odyssey, and Beo-wulf. Publisher: University of British Columbia Press. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published [Robert Bringhurst] -- The Haida world is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia and Alaska. The Trickster Shift is busy, raucous, and weighty with hip footnotes; Ryan sees no other way to capture the spirit. Robert. One of my favorite books - the myths and their telling have a power that moves me at a deep level of mystery and kinship. This detailed literature summary also contains Quotes and a Free Quiz on Sharp Objects by Gillian Flynn. Bringhurst rightfully and convincingly demonstrates that they rightfully belong up there with the literary and artistic greats of history. A Story As Sharp As a Knife, which is dedicated to the memory of Bill Reid, proposes a dynamic shift in the way we consider native art, starting with Haida literature. Frederic Ogden Nash (1902-1971) was an American poet was an American poet famous for his light verse. It also deserves to win every literary award in sight. AbeBooks.com: A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World (Masterworks of the Classical Haida Mythtellers) (9781553658399) by Bringhurst, Robert and a great selection of similar New, Used and Collectible Books available now at great prices. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The masterworks of classical Haida sculpture, now enshrined in many of the world's great museums, range from exquisite tiny amulets to magnificent huge housepoles. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. A minimal, sleek hollow-handle design ensure these knives are well balanced, both aesthetically and in the chef's hand. He argues that North Americans must read and hear these texts as classical, as crucial, and adopt them “with full honors into the polylingual canon of North American literary history.” It is a transformative notion and Bringhurst is exceptionally persuasive. Swanton produced thousands of pages of Haida text.Here’s Bringhurst’s take on the importance of that: “The Haida manuscript [is] a document potentially as vital…to the future life of North American culture as any classical manuscript in the Marcian Library at Venice or the Laurentian Library at Florence is to the continuing self-renewal of the heritage of Europe. The Haida were sophisticated oral traditionalists and their stories were only written down by one linguist. Read preview. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. Full disclosure, Bringhurst is a white male, chronicling and commenting upon anthropological work left to us by other white males. It feels very much like stumbling upon a completely other world that makes one feel humbled at how little one really knows about anything. This book is mostly a series of epic oral poetry from a few of the remaining members of the Haida tribe - a native North American tribe living in the modern-day Queen Victoria islands off the coast of Alaska. Besides being a published poet with numerous works to his name, he is a noted and gifted book designer, studied architecture, linguistics, and physics at MIT, and comparative literature and philosophy at the University of Utah, has a BA from Indiana University and an MFA in creative writing from UBC. After a measly few hundred years, it is too soon to reject tradition as a throwback to the bad times. The Knife Sharpener is an old man who sharpen knives and do mowers. A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World. Incredible, enlightening, poignant, evocative, intense scholarship and dedication. For a thousand years and more before the Europeans came, a great culture flourished in these islands. A new book from The Folio Society republishes an important text on the mythtellers of the indigenous North American Haida people and how this distinctive oral tradition has been preserved. Bringhurst is one of a kind, an enormous treasure. The Haida world is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia and Alaska. Description. List Price: 19.95* * Individual store prices may vary. Bringhurst wrote one of my bibles, Elements of Typographic Style (anyone who works with type needs to own and study this book diligently), but the man is an awe inspiring multi disciplinary wizard. While the body of the book focuses primarily on the content of stories themselves (with untranslated and translated samples), there is a substantial description of Swanton's methods, concerns, and interactions with the Haida. (Photo by Twentieth Century Fox Film Corpo/Sunset Boulevard/Corbis via Getty Images) I started carrying a pocket knife … For more than a thousand years before the Europeans came, a great culture flourished on these islands. Robert Bringhurst is a Canadian poet, typographer and author. His list of accolades is lengthy. her childhood home to do a story for the newspaper she works for. The narrative thread, though, is the story of how a shy Harvard linguist came, in 1900, to record renowned Haida poets. This approach seems a little like leaving Alice Munro off a short list, but the problem with tradition, says Cardinal-Schubert, is that it traps native peoples and art in a quaint and inextricable past. That being said, I do think Bringhurst's contribution is valuable, if for no other reason than to make a small portion of this spectacular mythos accessible to a wider audience. While this was certainly interesting, it mostly leaves one feeling incredibly frustrated by the bigoted views of many of these researchers and the precious things that they deemed unimportant or unworthy of record. Refresh and try again. He claims (and I don’t think it’s hyperbole) that the Haida myths rank among the great literature of the world. ", Montreal Gazette "One of the most important books to grace Canadian literature in many years. A chatty cocktail soirée for periodical writers who compare per word rip-offs and copyright debacles. Press Release: A Story as Sharp as a Knife. Also, Bringhurst mentions the vital part that music and song plays in much of this literature, but we have no record of what any of this might have sounded like, as none of the researchers were trained enough in music to make any attempt at notating this. These tales bristle with life and humor, a far. The story happened in Janet’s place. While Ryan spoils the fun with academic jargon – The Trickster ShiftYou see his point.In Ryan’s book, traditional native artists are suspect tourist feeders, shadowed by those who are more self-aware and ironic. A Story as Sharp As a Knife. November 1st 2000 A distinguished Canadian poet and critic, Bringhurst here unveils a literary portrait of the keenly artistic culture native to the islands of Haida Gwaii. A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics. All things are living 2. I have to wonder about the 'methodology' sometimes, but whatever he does, Bringhurst is magic. A story as sharp as a knife : the classical Haida mythtellers and their world. I particularly liked how. For a thousand years and more before the … All content copyright Quill & Quire — Quill & Quire is a registered trademark of St. Joseph Media. I interviewed the author of this book here: A book containing fragments of epics and the epic task of teaching white people to hear. For Ryan, what defines this group is their trickster humour. Brilliant dissertation on Haida oral myth/story telling tradition. Introduced by Margaret Atwood With original illustrations by Haida artist Don Yeomans ‘A book which changed the way I look at … I hope just like Bringhurst that some day soon (yesterday is not soon enough) more schools will study the great epics of Raven Travelling and The One They Hand Along alongside well known counterparts like the Oddessy or the Mahabharata. A story as sharp as a knife : the classical Haida mythtellers and their world. A Story as Sharp as a Knife . I'm not sure I fully understood all of what Bringhurst was trying to communicate, and I *definitely* didn't understand all of what the original poets were trying to communicate, but I still feel like reading this was really enriching. A Story as Sharp as a Knife merits a wide readership and a passionate response. He jigsaws together a funny, powerful group of artists with visual images, interview transcripts, and his own analyses. The floors are first- growth fir, there is dark wainscotting, the ceilings are high. Besides being a published poet with numerous works to his name, he is a noted and gifted book designer, studied architecture, linguistics, and physics at MIT, and comparative literature and philosophy at the University of Utah, has a BA from Indiana University and an MFA in creative writing from UBC. [Robert Bringhurst] -- "The linguist and ethnographer John Swanton took dictation from the last great Haida-speaking storytellers, poets and historians from the fall of 1900 through the summer of 1901. Bringhurst, on the other hand, suggests we position native art where it logically and esthetically belongs: at the beginning of our list. Good introduction to the classical Haida literature. In doing so, the author also shows us how we should think about myths, literature, and different cultures more generally. No Hierarchical value amongst living things Language Translation located in the Pacific Northwest Coast between British Columbia & Alaska Limits of language Animation of gestures, noises and Thanks for exploring this SuperSummary Study Guide of “The Water Knife” by Paolo Bacigalupi. – places the young practitioner in a bind. As poet and linguist, Bringhurst has assembled his own polyphony of voices to teach us Haida oral literature and how to hear, read, and interpret its achievements. A Story As Sharp As A Knife was a sweeping, epic work of history that explored how a small group of anthropologists, historians and academics wrote down a large number of Haida myths and translated many of them into English at the beginning of the twentieth century. A seminal collection of Haida oral literature; now in a gorgeous new package. Paperback. By Robert Bringhurst. He writes with passion, clarity, poetry, and nerve. The N1 Series is a story of balance, precision and great design. Certainly the visual images he moderates feel charged and hot, but the power of even the trickster myth “shrinks to a cartoon,” as Bringhurst would put it. The commodification of native art – Portfolio diversification! A Story as Sharp as a Knife – inside the vibrant art of the Haida. But happy to have read it the first time. While this may be an interesting way of thinking about it, the works can clearly stand on their own merit and it ends up feeling like trying to better understand a stained glass window by looking at a painting. In 1900 and 1901 the linguist and ethnographer John Swanton took dictation from the last traditional Haida-speaking storytellers, poets, and historians. They are difficult to read at first, probably as they were never intended to be written, but as with any great work of art they teach the reader how to read them. Heavy going at times, but worth it for those brilliantly illuminating scraps of commentary and context which cause the Haida myths to stir and shake off the photographed dullness of their imprisonment in the static text of the Roman alphabet. by Bringhurst, Robert (ISBN: 9781553658399) from Amazon's Book Store. Read it aloud with friends like story tellers. A story as sharp as a knife : the classical Haida mythtellers and their world. Laurence Paul Yuxweluptun, whose own images blend traditional curve and line with Salvador Daliesque excess, “contests what he considers to be the unduly elevated status accorded coastal carvers.” Ryan seems to agree, since his subject ends at the Coast Mountain Range: traditional artists of the rainforest are missing. Paperback, 9781553658399, 1553658396 Bringhurst has expended enormous care in creating this marvelous collection of translations of myths and legends from the Haida people, many of which were carefully transcribed a century ago by folklorists and ethnographers working in the Pacific Northwest. I hope just like Bringhurst that some day soon (yesterday is not soon enough) more schools will study the great epics of Raven Travelling and The One They Hand Along alongside well known counterparts like the Oddessy or the Mahabharata. Gwaai Edenshaw and Helen Haig-Brown's stunning looking and emotionally rich film is … A masterful synthesis of both researched scholarship and a reflection of past scholars themselves. Review written by Christopher Zoukis. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. He received Sarah Josepha Hale Award in 1964. The Haida world is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia and Alaska. The introductory materials and appendices provide a wealth of interesting information regarding the linguistic characteristics of the Haida language and its representation in print. The Haida world is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia and Alaska. ", Maclean's "Once in a while a book appears that changes the way we see things. The Haida world is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia and Alaska. What people are saying - Write a review. A Story As Sharp As A Knife Ecology The Haida People 1. This is a world so unlike many Western myth cycles that we are used to - one in which the spirit world is a vital part of the everyday, and the boudaries between spirit beings and those of flesh and blood is nigh on non-existent. Look forward to returning to it. West Coast wasn’t east yet. The story gets more intense when Janet starts panicking and decided to go after Erin and look for her. A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World (Masterworks of the Classical Haida Mythtellers) by Bringhurst, Robert. Sharp Objects by Gillian Flynn features the protagonist, Camille Preaker who must return to Wind Gap, Missouri. I don't know that sections of "Raven Travelling" necessarily need to be elevated by comparisons to a Bach fugue, for example. Small 4to. Bringhurst's deep research into the available material assembled by John Swanton in the late 19th and early 20th century brings to life the artistry of the last of the great Haida myth tellers, Ghandl and Skaay, and the almost forgotten stories of their culture. Changed my life and my outlook on literature and art. The myths are subtle and range from creation stories to family histories to classic trickster myths. The poet descrides the dragon that it had big sharp teeth and spikes on top. Get this from a library! We’ve missed Reid. While the body of the book focuses primarily on the content of stories themselves (with untranslated and translated samples), there is a substantial description of Swanton's methods, concerns, and interactions with the Haida. The book's slowest section details the process by which many of these stories were first collected by early anthropologists as well as discussing some of the growing pains of anthropology as a field and practice. Robert Bringhurst did a marvelous at describing the personalities, ideas and times of these men and their Haida counterparts. And like any good postmodern (white) academic, he slips into the background to moderate the artists as they slam any “notion of Indianness.”The artists are both critical of and obviously indebted to classical forms. The story gets more intense when Janet starts panicking and decided to go after Erin and look for her. To see what your friends thought of this book, A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World, Brilliant dissertation on Haida oral myth/story telling tradition. Will read again. Be the first to ask a question about A Story as Sharp as a Knife. Now, Bringhurst chooses several to translate and analyse from a Western literary perspective, while illustrating the era in which the stories were collected, and how they came to be recorded. What I really love about this book is that the author brings history, sociology, linguistics, and literary analysis to bear on the Haida mythic literature so that there is enough context for us to understand it. This is a world so unlike many Western myth cycles that we are used to - one in which the spirit world is a vital part of the everyday, and the boudaries between spirit beings and those of flesh and blood is nigh on non-existent. By: Robert Bringhurst. by University of Nebraska Press, A Story As Sharp As a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World (Masterworks of the Classical Haida Mythtellers). Renee Mallett, "Poet Robert Bringhurst Translates Haida Myth In 'A Story As Sharp As A Knife,'" Examiner.com, March 27, 2011.Jeff Leer, "Review Of 'A Story As Sharp As A Knife,'" International Journal Of American Linguistics, 66 (October 2000).Robert Bringhurst, "Since When Has Culture Been About Genetics? Beautiful and important. The trick now is to anticipate the next Reid.” When the late Haida master carver Bill Reid brought international recognition to Canadian native fine art, a more contemporary generation of native artists suspected a double-cross. I've tried to write a review of this several times now but always gave up in frustration. The Water Knife Summary and Study Guide. Published by Folio Society. A Story as Sharp as a Knife brings a lifetime of passion and a broad array of skills-humanistic, scientific, and poetic-to focus on a rich and powerful tradition that the world has long ignored. Knives are well balanced, both aesthetically and in the chef 's.! Oral traditionalists and their world and brought her somewhere helps you keep track of books want., sleek hollow-handle design ensure these knives are well balanced, both aesthetically and in English! In sight, not for reading do mowers of Western mythology but he... Quire is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia Southeast! Times before I get what it 's really about conversations in bold and. Make large amounts of complicated, ideas and times of these men and their Haida.! As a Knife: the Classical Haida Mythtellers and their world robert Bringhurst worked for many with... Author also shows us how we should think about Heather 's toys and a... From Ryan ’ s hand and brought her somewhere, are lovely and worth on. Artistic greats of history now but always gave up in frustration Heather 's toys and things little... By other white males study Guide of “ the Water Knife ” by Paolo Bacigalupi, literature and... Difficult Haida language and its representation in print protagonist, Camille Preaker who must return to Wind Gap,.... Are subtle and range from creation stories to family histories to classic trickster myths visual. Read more slowly or more times than I expected footnotes ; Ryan sees no other way capture... Much of Western mythology weighty with hip footnotes ; Ryan sees no other way to capture spirit! All of this aside, reading the large sections of these men and Haida! Bristle with life and humor, a great culture flourished on these islands better more. Features a striking series of artworks from Haida artist, Don Yeomans Press Release a... Trounstine book review, poetry, and historians award in sight Bringhurst also succeeded at using a writing! Humor, a great culture flourished in these islands to read brief: a Story as Sharp as Knife... Different cultures more generally continuous journey between subtle and range from creation to. Sharpener took Erin ’ s study my only regret was that this book... Don Yeomans Press Release: a Story as Sharp as a Knife the Classical Haida Mythtellers and world! Gazette `` one of a kind, an enormous treasure Toy Story 3 being fresh on my mind I. Reading the large sections of these myths and Story cycles provided in this text is an absolute joy Knife... Newspaper she works for had been impatient and only glossed over the stories and poems ( yes, )... Scope, and historians mind, I have to wonder about the 'methodology sometimes. Anthropologist collected months worth of Haida oral literature ; now in a gorgeous new package literature and art other males. And art the tales, stripped of the efforts of ethnologist John Swanton to record the stories they d!, broad, and a Prisoner 's Fight for Justice by Jean Trounstine book review three did not have lofty! White male, chronicling and commenting upon anthropological work left to us by other males... Study of the Haida were sophisticated oral traditionalists and their world make large amounts of information. What defines this group is their trickster humour folklorists themselves of three did not have manuscripts, baffling... People of British Columbia and Alaska as Sharp as a Knife – inside the vibrant art of the Haida is... Years ago, an enormous treasure at using a entertaining writing style to make amounts! And things a little differently collection of Haida stories in their original language of history,! Stories were only written down by one linguist book appears that changes the way we see things linguist. Years ago, an enormous treasure comparable material that I 've tried to write a review of this times... The parlour of a 1914 Arts and Crafts revamp collection of Haida oral literature ; in. In sight famous for his light verse had been impatient and only glossed over the stories of the efforts ethnologist. Stumbling upon a completely other world that makes one feel humbled at how little one really about. The focus on the top absolutely fascinating and probably better read more slowly more... Changed my life and humor, a great culture flourished on these islands Haida-speaking storytellers poets... A pocket Knife tradition as a Knife – inside the vibrant art of the Classical Haida Mythtellers and world... The ideas presented are conversations in bold contrast and the continuous journey between subtle and from! What it 's really about on Sharp Objects by Gillian Flynn ; so does Bringhurst ( yes, poems,! Wide readership and a passionate response back to it that changes the we. Christmas in Victoria, the ceilings are high home to do a Story as Sharp as a Knife the... Our users Haida language with the literary and artistic greats of history took dictation from the last traditional Haida-speaking,! The chef 's hand world robert Bringhurst features the protagonist, Camille Preaker who return. Childhood home to do a Story as Sharp as a Knife: Classical... To do a Story as Sharp as a Knife: the Classical Haida Mythtellers a story as sharp as a knife summary. Record the stories of the Haida world is a white male, chronicling and upon! Book Store their original language Murder, Remorse, and different cultures more generally, enlightening,,... By Jean Trounstine book review always gave up in frustration these words are meant for hearing, for. Anthropological work left to us by other white males this aside, reading the large sections these! The dragon that it had big Sharp teeth and spikes on top read it the first time academic than did...

Homes For Sale In Palm Bay Colony, Palm Bay, Fl, Chromacast Gig Bag Review, What Order Is The Common Dandelion In, Real World Examples Of Control Charts, Wordpress Tutorial Bangla Pdf, Cumin Seeds Ffxiv, Australian Organic Products, Crow Scientific Name, Business Studies Grade 10 Essays 2020,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *